Killing Them Softly

01 h 37 m
Andrew Dominik
Brad Pitt, Scoot McNairy, Ben Mendelsohn
"Gritty Realism Meets Stylish Satire in `Killing Them Softly`"

Posted Thursday, Nov 30, 2023 96

Andrew Dominik`s 2012 film `Killing Them Softly` is an unapologetically raw depiction of organized crime and capitalist decay. Based on the novel `Cogan`s Trade` by George V. Higgins, the story follows enforcer Jackie Cogan (Brad Pitt) as he investigates a heist that occurred during a high-stakes mob-protected poker game. Set against the backdrop of the 2008 financial crisis and presidential election, the film`s narrative weaves through the criminal underworld, revealing a microcosm of American greed and disillusionment.

The movie boldly addresses themes of economic disenchantment, systematic corruption, and the brutal efficiency of crime as a business. Its tone is cynical and atmospheric, with a blend of hard-edged dialogue and a calculated visual style that verges on the neo-noir.

Brad Pitt delivers a standout performance, portraying Cogan with a cool detachment that underscores his professional approach to his violent work. The supporting cast, including Scoot McNairy, Ben Mendelsohn, and James Gandolfini, offer textured portrayals of characters navigating a world marred by desperation and power struggles.

Director Andrew Dominik constructs the film with a stylistic confidence, imbuing it with a stark realism punctuated by moments of visceral action and dark humor. His use of allegory to parallel the crime story with broader economic commentaries imbues the film with a resonant satirical edge.

Killing Them Softly movie review

The nuanced soundtrack and thought-provoking score by Marc Streitenfeld enhance the gritty aesthetic, underscoring the film`s moments of tension and portraying the underlying resignation of the characters` fates.

Cinematographer Greig Fraser captures the film`s bleak landscapes and stylized violence with a sharp eye, crafting visuals that reinforce the film`s thematic weight and narrative grit.

The film`s production design, with its dreary urban settings and stark interiors, viscerally encapsulates the world of low-level crime, grounding the narrative in a palpable sense of place that reflects its thematic concerns.

`Killing Them Softly` utilizes its special effects judiciously, crafting realistic portrayals of violence that hit with a shocking impact, contributing to the film`s unflinching approach to depicting the world of crime.

Killing Them Softly movie review

The editing artfully balances the storytelling, moving with a steady rhythm that mirrors the deliberate pacing of the narrative, creating an engaging experience that allows the viewer to digest the layered dialogue and complex interactions.

The pacing methodically unfolds the plot, lending sufficient time for character development and thematic exploration, ensuring the film`s socio-political subtext resonates as strongly as its crime-driven plot.

The dialogue is sharp and often potent, with an air of authenticity to the language. It captures the characters` philosophies and the larger commentary on society with a subversive wit.

Some might argue that the film`s broader socio-economic critiques weigh down the narrative, leading to a film experience that can feel didactic or overly stylized in its messaging. Additionally, the pacing may appear slow to those expecting a more traditional gangster film.

As a film critic, `Killing Them Softly` stands out as a compellingly crafted fusion of crime drama and provocative commentary. Its raw energy and political undercurrents offer a cinematic experience that is both intellectually engaging and viscerally affecting, painting a grim portrait of the American dream gone awry.

Also check out these reviews:

Looking for something else? Search our movie reviews: